Quaterly Newsletter Issue #08
July-September 2024
Dear Readers,
 
Greetings!


In this eighth edition of the InnovTech@CUTS newsletter, we present the findings from our project report on multi-party privacy among consumers of digital credit in India. The findings shed light on consumer attitudes and concerns related to the use of digital financial services. For example, our research indicates that while platforms collect vast amounts of data, low-income and rural users are not the primary beneficiaries of digital credit, contrary to common belief. Many users believe they must trade their data to access digital financial services. They also observed that mobile applications often lack features to obtain consent from all parties to whom data belonged before sharing it.
 
Further, we hosted and participated in events that shaped the discourse on emerging technologies, including Artificial Intelligence. We are also actively involved in studies related to data privacy, generative AI-related misinformation, cloud services, and capacity-building initiatives for women, youth and organisations led by them in digital and cyber policymaking, among other areas.
 

 
 
Amol Kulkarni
Director (Research)
CUTS International
“My data or yours?” Unravelling Multi-Party Privacy among Consumers of Digital Credit in India
Janaki Srinivasan, V Sridhar, Amol Kulkarni, T K Srikanth, and Asheef Iqubbal

 
The operation of digital financial services (DFS) relies on a mix of consumer personal data and data collected from various sources, such as social media, by fintech platforms. This data is often shared with third parties for services like insurance and collections. Against this backdrop, CUTS International, in collaboration with IIIT Bangalore (IIIT-B), conducted a research study to explore attitudes and concerns regarding multi-party privacy among DFS stakeholders.
 
We conducted an experimental study with 59 IIIT-B students, surveyed over 2200 DFS users (including 460 digital borrowers), consultations with industry representatives, a roundtable discussion with experts, and interviews and observations with 19 DFS users. Additionally, we compared the data collection and sharing practices of digital credit providers with the existing regulatory framework.
 
Key findings include:
  • About 25 percent of digital borrowers prefer digital credit for benefits like no-collateral loans. Trust develops gradually, starting with small loans.
  • 61 percent of users are neutral about personal data protection, while a quarter shares their data for convenience. Few users take steps to protect their data, citing limited opt-out options.
  • Users desire a consent mechanism for co-owned data sharing; however, app designs often lack this feature.
  • Location and contact data cause the greatest concern, with 50 per cent of users reporting spam calls after registering for DFS.
  • Digital lending guidelines should prioritise consumer protection by introducing privacy metrics to help users identify reliable apps.
Read full report here and/or listen to the AI-generated podcast of the report here.

Op-eds

More Than Just Flight: India’s Drone Age
Anjali Shekhawat and Dhruv Bansal
The Geopolitics, August 06, 2024

Media Coverage

Experts call Airtel’s spam tool promising, but flag privacy issues
Financial Express, September 30, 2024
 
Digital credit users aware of privacy concerns, but don’t do much to prevent privacy intrusion: Study
The Hindu, September 10, 2024
 
After heartburn and locked horns, digital competition bill pushed to next year
Livemint, September 09, 2024
 
Digital antitrust law may be for Big Tech only
Financial Express, August 12, 2024
 
MeitY may ask MCA to keep ex-ante out of Digital Competition Bill for now
The Economic Times, July 15, 2024
 
Digital gatekeeper tag for Zomato, Myntra, Nykaa adds compliance rules to cart
Livemint, July 08, 2024
 
CUTS Institute for Regulation & Competition report explores the potential consumer impact of the Digital Competition Bill for users of Paytm, Jio, MakeMyTrip and IRCTC
MediaNama, July 05, 2024
 
Digital Competition Bill may impact user experience on online platforms
Business Standard, July 01 2024
 
Digital Competition Bill May Compromise Seamlessness of Digital Apps, Says Report
Inc42 Media, July 01, 2024

Representations

Aakarsh Bhargav participated in the 2nd Annual International Conference on ‘Competition Law in the Digital Age: Contextualising Global Experiences’ which was organised by The Dialogue in New Delhi on August 08, 2024.
Workshop on “My Data or Yours?” Unravelling Multi-Party Privacy (MPP) Among Consumers of Digital Credit in India
August 27, 2024

 
Digital financial services, particularly digital lending, rely heavily on co-owned data. While this data is crucial for enabling access, it also raises significant multi-party privacy concerns. CUTS International and IIIT Bangalore conducted a comprehensive study using controlled experiments, large-scale surveys, observational tests, and stakeholder consultations to understand the perspectives and trade-offs involved. Key findings from this research were presented in a workshop that featured insights from leading experts in the digital finance sector.
 
The speakers included Rakesh Maheshwari, former Senior Director and Group Coordinator, (Cyber Laws and Data Governance), MeitY; Misha Sharma, Head, Household Finance, Dvara Research; Garima Agrawal, Researcher, Centre for Internet and Society; Jatinder Handoo, Chief Executive Officer, Digital Lenders Association of India; Ranjeet Rane, Head of Research, Reserve Bank Innovation Hub; and Sumit Ghoshal, Senior Partner, AZB & Partners.
 
More about the workshop is available
here.
AI and the Future of Work in India
July 26, 2024

 
CUTS International organised a webinar on ‘AI and the future of work in India’. The webinar explored AI’s diverse impacts on the Indian workforce and economy, including job creation and transformation, the urgent need for upskilling, and the unique challenges and opportunities it brings to the Micro, Small and Medium-sized Enterprise (MSME) sector, a key driver of India's growth.
 
More about the webinar is available
here.
Governing the AI Ecosystem
New Delhi, July 11, 2024

 
CUTS International participated as a community partner in a roundtable discussion on 'Governing the AI Ecosystem’ organised by MediaNama at the India Habitat Centre, New Delhi, on July 11, 2024.
 
The discussion aimed to explore how liability should be distributed among different players in the AI ecosystem, the feasibility of preventing certain kinds of AI outputs, and the regulatory approach India should adopt to enable that AI ecosystem.
 
The event report is available
here.
Pact for the Future, Global Digital Compact and Declaration on Future Generations
United Nations
 
Digital platform services inquiry 2020-25
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
 
Decoding India’s AI Governance Strategy and its Implications for the U.S.-India Bilateral Relationship
Indian Public Policy Review 
 
Online privacy: Is staying offline the only way to fully secure it?
LiveMint
 
Open-source imperative for India’s public sector
Hindustan Times
CUTS International

Jaipur • New Delhi • Chittorgarh • Kolkata • Hanoi • Nairobi • Lusaka • Accra • Geneva • Washington DC

Copyright © 2024 CUTS International, All rights reserved.

Facebook     X LinkedIn